It’s a common dilemma when you’re searching for a reliable used pickup truck: should you go for the legendary Toyota Hilux or the refined Volkswagen Amarok? Both vehicles offer distinct advantages, and your choice ultimately depends on your specific needs.
The Toyota Hilux has built its reputation on reliability and durability. If you’re looking for a workhorse that can handle tough conditions, the Hilux won’t disappoint. Its target audience includes farmers, construction workers, and outdoor enthusiasts who need dependable transportation in challenging environments. You’ll find that most used Hilux models come with either a 2.4L or 2.8L diesel engine, known for their excellent fuel economy and strong pulling power.
Common issues with used Hilux models include timing belt replacements around 100,000 miles, occasional injector problems on the 2.4L engine, and rust on older models, particularly around the wheel arches. However, these problems are generally predictable and relatively inexpensive to fix.
The Volkswagen Amarok, on the other hand, brings a more sophisticated approach to the pickup segment. Your driving experience will feel more car-like, with superior road handling and interior comfort. The Amarok targets business owners, urban contractors, and families who want a practical vehicle that doesn’t compromise on comfort. The 2.0L twin-turbo and 3.0L V6 diesel engines offer impressive performance, with the V6 variant providing particularly strong acceleration.
When examining used Amaroks, you should watch out for DSG gearbox issues on automatic models, electrical glitches in the infotainment system, and timing chain problems on early 2.0L engines. These repairs can be costly, so thorough service history checks are important.
For off-road capability, the Hilux generally performs better in extreme conditions, thanks to its proven 4×4 system and higher ground clearance. The Amarok compensates with better on-road dynamics and more precise handling, making it ideal if you spend most of your time on paved roads.
Your budget will also influence your decision. Used Hilux models typically hold their value better and cost less to maintain. The Amarok often comes with a higher initial purchase price but offers more modern features and better comfort.
If you’re prioritizing pure utility and reliability, the Hilux is your best bet. Its simple mechanical design means fewer things can go wrong, and parts are readily available. However, if you want a more refined driving experience and don’t mind potentially higher maintenance costs, the Amarok offers a more premium feel and better everyday usability.
Both vehicles can tow around 3,500kg and carry approximately one tonne in the bed, so payload capacity shouldn’t be a deciding factor. Your choice should ultimately come down to your primary use case: choose the Hilux for hardcore work duties and off-road adventures, or select the Amarok for a more comfortable daily driver that can still handle weekend work tasks.